- Atiqah Maisarah
The question of whether unsecured creditors, such as suppliers, trade creditors, or service providers, have the right to intervene in an application for Judicial Management Order has been a subject of intense legal debate. While secured creditors enjoy explicit statutory rights to oppose an application for judicial management, the position of unsecured creditors remains unsettled due to divergent judicial interpretations and a current conflict at the appellate courts level.
Unsecured creditors’ right to intervene and oppose a judicial management application is not expressly provided for in either the Companies Act 2016 or the Corporate Rescue Mechanism Rules 2018. Case law reflects two distinct judicial approaches on whether an unsecured creditor may be heard.
The Strict statutory approach
The first line of authorities adopts a strict statutory interpretation, holding that unsecured creditors lack locus standi to intervene and/or oppose the making of a judicial management order. In Leadmont Development Sdn Bhd v Infra Segi Sdn Bhd and another suit [2019] 8 MLJ 473, Justice Wong Chee Lin JC held that based on the relevant provisions of the Companies Act 2016, only secured creditors have standing to oppose a judicial management order, whereas other creditors are strictly limited to objecting to the nomination of the proposed judicial manager at the hearing rather than opposing the application itself. This reasoning was adopted by Azmi Ariffin J in Million Westlink Sdn Bhd v Maybank Investment Bank Berhad & Ors [2019] MLJU 1721, where the court held that unsecured creditors have no legal standing to express objections to the making of a judicial management order.
The rationale is often reasoned by the distinction between commercial and legal interests. As established in earlier jurisprudence by the Federal Court in Tong Swee King v Pegang Mining Co Ltd & Ors [1967] 2 MLJ 214, an unsecured creditor’s interest is typically purely commercial, affecting their pocket rather than granting a proprietary right over company assets. Furthermore, allowing every unsecured creditor to intervene could make litigation impracticable if numerous small creditors were to hinder court processes with individual objections.
The Purposive approach
A contrasting approach emerged shortly thereafter, favoring broader access to justice through purposive interpretation of the Act. In Goldpage Assets Sdn Bhd v Unique Mix Sdn Bhd [2020] MLJU 723, Nadzarin Wok Nordin JC adopted a purposive interpretation of the Companies Act 2016, holding that the court’s jurisdiction ought not to be readily restricted and that access to justice should remain open to all creditors, including unsecured creditors. This principle was subsequently followed in cases such as Best Re (L) Ltd v Chubb Samaggi Insurance Public Co Ltd [2021] MLJU 310, Maju-TH Sdn Bhd [2025] 8 MLJ 875, and Novabrite Lighting Sdn Bhd v Emrail Sdn Bhd [2025] 11 MLJ 275.
It is significant to note that the High Court decision in Million Westlink was eventually overturned by the Court of Appeal, which held that unsecured creditors do possess sufficient interest to be heard in judicial management proceedings.
The conflicting Court of Appeal decision
However, the issue of whether an unsecured creditor has a right to intervene in a judicial management proceeding resurfaced in the case of Desa Tiasa Sdn Bhd v CME Group Berhad & Anor [2025] 1 MLRAU 397. The Court of Appeal in the case of Desa Tiasa ruled that based on the plain reading of the Companies Act 2026 and Rule 13 of Rules 2018, only allow secured creditors or those with the right to appoint a receiver to oppose the application. Adopting the principles of statutory interpretation from the Federal Court in Tebin bin Mostapa v Hulba-Danyal bin Balia & Anor [2020] 4 MLJ 721, the court held that where the language of the statute is clear and unambiguous, the Court must give effect to the plain meaning of the act.
This ruling created a direct conflict at the appellate level. While the Court of Appeal in Million Westlink recognized the standing of unsecured creditors, the Court of Appeal in Desa Tiasa ruled otherwise, effectively barring them from intervening in a judicial management application.
The Court of Appeal decision of Desa Tiasa is now pending appeal to the Federal Court whereby the Federal Court in November, 2025 allowed the following questions of law:-
Question 1: Whether an unsecured creditor may intervene and be heard in JM proceedings filed by another unsecured creditor pursuant to Section 405 of the CA 2016 read together with Rule 13 of the CRM 2018?
Question 2: Whether an unsecured judgment creditor holding a not appealable final judgment may be heard in proceedings to appoint a judicial manager over a judgment debtor?
Question 3: Whether Rule 13 of the CRM 2018 can be read to give preference to the rights of one unsecured creditor over the rights of another unsecured creditor?
Question 4: Whether Rule 13 of the CRM 2018 prohibits the involvement of all unsecured creditors in JM proceedings, regardless of whether the said unsecured creditor is in support of or objects to said proceedings?
The Federal Court is expected to hear and deliver its decision on the above leave questions on 22nd July 2026.
In conclusion, while the statutory position relating to secured creditors is clear, the position of unsecured creditors remains deeply unsettled due to conflicting Court of Appeal authorities.
The forthcoming decision of the Federal Court will be of critical importance to Malaysia’s judicial management landscape. It will finally determine whether unsecured creditors possess a legally enforceable right to participate in judicial management proceedings, bringing much-needed certainty to insolvency practitioners, lenders, companies, and the broader commercial community as the corporate rescue regime continues to evolve.
General Disputes Resolution and Appellate Division
General Disputes Resolution and Appellate Division
General Disputes Resolution and Appellate Division
General Disputes Resolution and Appellate Division
This article is prepared and published by
Messrs. Ben Lee & Sharen
Advocates & Solicitors


