The Secured Creditor’s Veto: The Power of Section 409 of the Companies Act, 2016

While Judicial Management is a powerful tool for debtors, it is not absolute. The Companies Act 2016 (“the Act”) acknowledges the superior contractual and proprietary rights of secured creditors through Section 409(b) of the Act. While this veto power is not absolute as the Court retains discretion under Section 405(5)(a) of the Act to consider overriding public interest justifying the granting of a JM order, the right to intervene and oppose afforded to secured creditors in JM applications remains clear, unequivocal, and firmly entrenched in law.

The rationale for this veto lies in the sanctity of contract. Banks and other financial institutions often lend money based on the security of a debenture, which gives them a specific right to take over the company’s assets via receivership if the company defaults. Section 409 ensures that a Court ordered rescue does not unilaterally override these pre-existing commercial agreements.

This is further supported by Rule 13(1) of the Companies (Corporate Rescue Mechanism) Rules 2018 which identifies only two types of creditors who are explicitly entitled to notice and the right to oppose the order namely those with the right to appoint a receiver and secured creditors. By limiting the veto to these specific classes, the Act ensures that the only parties who can halt the process are those whose proprietary interests are most directly at risk and who already have an alternative recovery mechanism in place.

Hence, if the bank believes the process is more likely to yield a better recovery than a forced sale in receivership, they may choose not to object, thereby allowing the company to proceed with the Court sanctioned rescue under the protection of the moratorium.

Do stay tuned to our next article that discusses on the topic of whether unsecured creditors have a say to intervene JM Application as well or not.

General Disputes Resolution and Appellate Division

This article is prepared and published by
Messrs. Ben Lee & Sharen
Advocates & Solicitors